3" 12 gauge slugs seemed to recoil as heavily as anything I ever shot. At close range ideal for home defense the 20 gauge is just as effective as the 12 gauge. According to Chuck Hawks recoil table the .30-30 produces 10.6 lbs. shooting the 150 grain bullet has a felt recoil of: 10.6 lbs. I love it. at 2800) 7.5: 15.8: 20 gauge, 2.75" (7/8 oz. Join Date: Jun 2013; Posts: 82; Share Tweet #6. Lets say youre a 12-gauge shooter toting a typical sporting clays or waterfowl type shotgun weighing in at close to eight pounds. MY FACEBOKK LINK! 10 Gauge vs 12 Gauge For Hunting. Hunting section, what are your plans for with the 170 grain bullet. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page. When choosing between 28 gauge vs. 20 gauge shotguns, remember that 20 gauge shots are yellow while the 28s are red. Re: Help me decide! but if the pigs are big I would reccomend a m marlin in the new .308 leverevolution bullet those have more nock-down power, the 30-30 will seem mild compared with the 12 ga. i have taken hogs,deer and a black bear with the 30-30 in the past and i used the Federal 150 gr shells,if i was to take a start using it today i would use the new hornady leverevolution ammo and top the rifle off with one of cabala's bullet drop compensating scopes made for this new hornady ammo,by the way the new ammo has a safe to use in tubular magazines soft pointed bullet,unlike the round nose ammo i use to use, The 30-30 has very mild recoil, and is comfortable to shoot. By the way the shotgun is a old browning o/u. at 1220) 6.5: 21.0 Copyright 2015, 2016 by Chuck Hawks. So a .30-30 Winchester round exits the barrel with kinetic energy equal to the energy required for linear vertical displacement of 1890 pounds through a one foot distance, while a .308 Winchester round exiting the barrel has energy equal to the amount required to displace 2620 pounds over the same one foot distance. Want to move to our town? But on the othrhand neither one is for the recoil shy. The nice thing about the 45-70 and .444 is that when you shoot something, it's down right there. Shooting the exact same load, the heavier the gun, the lower the recoil energy; a gun that weighs twice as much, kicks half as hard. I assume that being an experienced shooter, you are already aware of all that. It is no wonder flinching (and missing!) Comment. In my 30-30 I prefer Winchester ammo. 12 Gauge Slug Range Chart Lewisburg District Umc. Does the colt ace shoot as good as the 1911 gold match? Whats a good hunting double rifle for driven wild boar hunting? Jump to Latest Follow 1 - 13 of 13 Posts. We also sell Ammo in bulk, so if you are looking to save money or stock up, consider our deals on Bulk Ammo. That can result in a dramatic increase in kick when, for example, 3", 1-1/4 ounce Magnum shells are fired in a 20 gauge So you'll do fine with that .30-30. Shotgunworld Recoil Measurements By Shotgun. Factors to Consider When Choosing 28 Gauge vs. 20 Gauge Shotguns. Much better for a home defense gun is a 20 gauge. In the real world, firearms chambered for smaller cartridges are typically built lighter than firearms chambered for more powerful cartridges. with (usually the lightest bullet weight available for the 30-30), whether "Nosler-tip" or soft-point; I've gotten comparable results with Federal, Remington and Winchester brands, regarding accuracy/penetration. Again, there is some overlap, but the .45-70 Government remains a much stronger cartridge. Shotguns pellets are designed to spread after you fire limited by the choke size. Note that the most powerful shotgun loads generate recoil comparable to elephant rifle cartridges. - What do you feel has more felt recoil 30.06 or 12 ga. The lighter felt recoils make it easier to make follow up shots rapidly. A Does anyone still believe Kyle Rittenhouse is guilty after watching the full video compilation? Worst thing: shoot leaning over a picnic table as a shooting bench with an unpadded butt on my collar bone. Old Stinky. with the 170 grain bullet. the 30/30 dont hardly kick at all i like ur selection it has 12 pounds of recoil in a 7lb rifle a 30.06 has 21lbs and ull also be able to use it for deer to id get a used 336 u can probly find 1 for 200-250 then i get a old redfield widefield 4x scope off ebay for 100$ and the best ammo for that old gun is the hornady lever evolution, the 30-30 with about a 1/4 inch recoil pad kicks more like a 20 guage. There isnt any problem using a 20 gauge shotgun for home defense. I like the 150 gr and the 170 gr. A 12 gauge typically pushes out 4200 Joules of energy compared to 3000 for a 3006. Similarly, people will use a 12-gauge for small-game hunting like rabbits and squirrels. 12 Gauge Shotgun. A 125 grain 30-30 will recoil even less. 10 Gauge vs. 12 Gauge for Home Defense Most 10-gauge shotguns weigh over 10 pounds. The .30-30 Winchester is one of the great success stories in American firearms. The shorter the barrel, the heavier the recoil, usually; your rifle has a 20" barrel, which should give moderate recoil. Any reccomendations on ammo will be good too thanks! Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and the Yahoo Answers website is now in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. at 3000) 8.0: 17.1: 12 gauge, 2.75" (1 oz. Taming the 12 Gauge: Shotgun Recoil Management. Using a 30-30, you shouldn't need anything more than 150gr. The 12 gauge actually "kicks" harder, but you feel it more with the '94. For those that are looking at the 20 gauge for the same purpose. Sighting in may present you with some difficulties, as you need to be more precise than with any shotgun. Taming the 12 Gauge: Shotgun Recoil Management - YouTube. Gun weight is an important, and inversely proportional, component of recoil. at 2400) 7.5: 10.6: 7mm-08 Rem. at 1200) 6.0: 12.8.308 Win. Reply. by keen Fri Sep 27, 2013 1:37 am Greetings, Doing a bit of research on different calibres and cartridges for a hunting rifle, obviously cartridges from the 30 cal family are popular and .308 win is high on the list. The 12 gauge has less recoil, but you may still feel it because its lighter. Hopes for herd immunity in jeopardy, poll reveals. There is a reason why it has helped hunters to take so much gane: It works. Retay vs Benelli vs Franchi 20 or 12 gau. After about five slugs my shoulder begins to protest. farewell? or .450 Nitro Express rifle even once will casually buy a box of 12 gauge, 3-inch Magnum shot shells for hunting season and shoot all 25 shells at a single sitting. Remember, bullet placement comes first. If youre shooting a 1-ounce lead load with an instrumental velocity of 1145 feet per second, that load in your eight-pound gun is generating about 19.86 foot/pounds of free recoil; lets call it 20 ft./lbs. A .308 Winchester, 150 grain round generates about 16 ft-lbs of recoil whereas the 12-gauge generates anywhere from about 25 to 50 ft-lbs. (140 gr. (140 gr. At any rate, I feel the .308 recoil is very manageable. According to Chuck Hawks recoil index: A .30-30 weighting 7.5 lbs. This gives you 20% more pellets at only 10% less density at 50% of the recoil. Shotgun Recoil Chart Amr. with it's straight stock, it actually enhances the felt recoil. There isn't much of a difference in recoil between the 30-30 and 12ga hunting loads (except for the "high-velocity" loads), but if you don't hold the butt firmly enough to your shoulder, it will give you a nasty bruising. 12 posts Page 1 of 1. Take a few shots with a friend's .30-30, and see what you think. I have killed, deer, javelina, elk, mountain lion, bear and yes even 2 feral hogs in texas with a 30-30, so don't let anyone tell you it won't do the job.. Good luck and have a great hunting experience. Take a look at those new Hornady rounds. I looking to by a rilfe for pigs i will like it in 30/30 (more then likley be getting a marlin model 336) im 14 and i can shoot 100+ 12 gauge target loads without any pain the next morning. at 2700) 8.0: 20.3: 20 gauge, 2.75" (1 oz. As a rule of thumb, when it comes to hunting, muzzle energy is what many hunters look at Team owner draws ire for list of 5 most important Lakers, A country in crisis: India faces major oxygen shortage, Faith, freedom, fear: Rural America's vaccine skeptics. at 1200) 6.5: 16.1.270 Win. Therefore, gun weight is crucial to determining the recoil a shooter experiences when he or she pulls the trigger. As for ammo, the best choice right now is the new "lever revolution" ammo. is so common. Still have questions? I get assigned the thickest crap to walk through. I have the same 30-30 you are talking about.Been shooting since I was 11. 30-30 still has a pretty big following though. H ..to answer your question, the light 'Trapdoor' loads kick about the same as a 20 gauge slug, or maybe a 12 gauge low-brass load, though recoil can be a subjective thing. Anyone else nostalgic looking over the Foonblotz catalog? Shoot your 12 gauge pump or O/U shotgun from a bench rest some day and you will see what I mean. Joined Oct 24, 2007 Messages 8,455 Location Wilson County, TN. .30-30 Win. A common question among shooters is how rifle and shotgun recoil compares. Mar 26, 2020 #12 REN Well-Known Member. This helps in countering the effect of large caliber recoil. (Remember, hunting rifles are usually equipped with a scope and shotguns are not.). Shooters who would never think of shooting a .416 Rem. (150 gr. The marlin has less "felt" recoil because of it's stock design. Getting to Know the .30-30 Winchester. Here is a nice 12 Gauge shell with oz of shot and a 1,200 fps muzzle velocity. Slug Guns Twenty Gauge Vs Twelve What Is Better. I'd use the 170 grain bullets on hog, but even the 150 grain rounds would work fine. knock down power you can get out of a 30-30. [ 1] On top of this, a slug from a 12 gauge is typically 1 ounce compared to perhaps 180 grains or 0.4 ounces for the 3006. So what id the difference between the recoil of a 30/30 and 12 gauge? When fired from the same Model 101 Field, its going to generate 27.0 ft lbs recoil energy. 30-30 vs 308 win - Why still shoot the 30-30? The 3 1/2 12 gauge shells are best suited for waterfowl hunting, particularly for geese. Of the three, I prefer the .30-.30 as it has less recoil than the 12 gauge and is more accurate than the 44 mag. I recommend the use a shooting table, or similar setup, while you sight in -- just to help eliminate the "human error" factor. I am glad for that because it is all can really find for it w/o mail ordering. The 336 is a lot of fun in a classic lever action. How loud does lightning sound close up compared to other loud things such as a shotgun? Either should be fine. at 2860) 8.0: 12.6: 28 gauge, 2.75" (3/4 oz. . Lets compare the 30-30 vs. 30-06 and see if either is ideal for your needs. The 'Trapdoor' loads however, are by no means uncomfortable in any 45/70 I have ever shot one in, including a H&R Handi-Rifle and a Ruger #1, both Some people describe the recoil impulse from a 12-gauge as a push as opposed to the .308 rifle as more of a jerk. All rights reserved. A Shotgun Recoil Example. (150 gr. Are you considering the purchase of a .30-30? I can plink with it all day on the shoulder with no discomfort. * Great choice nothing to be concerned about as far as recoil goes. http://www.facebook.com/pages/Heather-Lacroix/183081175038375I'm Heather LaCroix and I love to get out and have some fun! However, is is worth noting that shotguns are generally fired at moving targets from a standing position at the trap, skeet or sporting clays range. The lightest 2 n 3/4" 12 gauge round is rated at 17.3 lbs. But then, so does my .54 caliber muzzle-loader. Using the 20 gauge can have a lot less recoil than the 12 gauge. We offer choices of excellent quality range ammo, the most proven hollow points and specialty rounds in all of the most popular calibers. The lower recoil The 12 gauge is so popular because its powerful enough to hunt most species of game, but the recoil of a 12 gauge is much more manageable than the 10 gauge. Conversely, at rifle ranges, rifles are normally fired from a sitting position at a bench rest at static targets and the shooters attention is focused on the gun's sights (or scope). Interesting note about ammo; As I mentioned my 30-30 loves Winchester ammo, but it's big brother, my 35 Rem likes 200 gr Remmington ammo! There are a great many rifle cartridges, far more than there are shotgun gauges. the real difference in the recoil comes from the "straight stock" design of the Winchester '94. Shotgunworld Weight Vs Largeness Of Shotguns. AND, combined with the new powder, it has increased the effective range of the 30-30 by another 100 yards. Another area of excellence for both 28 gauge vs. 20 gauge recoil is home defense. As a rule of thumb, when it comes to hunting, muzzle energy is what many hunters look Shooting 1oz. Having a 12-gauge for home defense is basically the norm. * Use 170 grain ammo.*. The heavier 12 gauge slug has the mightiest recoil of all. of recoil with the 150 grain bullet and 11.0 lbs. Favorite Answer. Do not forget that gun weight is a crucial factor in the recoil equation, inversely proportional to recoil. The shooter's attention is necessarily focused on the target, not the gun. RandyC is correct about the difference in recoil between the Winchester and the Marlin, I had both and sold the Marlin, I regret that decision, My 94 has the 16" barrel and plastic butt pad and the recoil is still not as stout as any of my shotguns. slugs with the shotgun,and around 165.gr. Here's $10,000 and a bike. Get your answers by asking now. no hay cono para poner altavoz en llamadas. If you put it where it should be, most likely any ammo out there will do the job. Recoil, to be honest, I don't think about it.. Increase the gun weight by, say, 25% and the recoil goes down by 25%. Where as the .444 recoil is like a very stiff 3" 12 gauge round. The .308 in this latter case will usually produce much less recoil than the 12 gauge, which can approach .375 H&H recoil levels with the right load and weapon. If we were to fire it out of a 7 lb Winchester Model 101 Field, it would generate 13.9 ft lbs recoil energy. The 12 gauge slug can bull it's way through brush a bit better but no gun is brush proof. Guns - 12 ga. vs 30.06 recoil ?? According to Chuck Hawks recoil table the .30-30 produces 10.6 lbs. With practice, it's relatively mild. Best thing I ever did for recoil: get a good recoil pad. Post Cancel. There certainly will not be any issues regarding "is this gun enough" when you go after those pigs; a .223 is often enough for pigs, and can be effective on deer when shot accurately (.223 is not recommended for use on deer, though). 45-70 vs 12g recoil. Hold it properly and I think you'll find it's very easy to work with the .30-30. at 1180) 7.5: 17.3.30-06 (180 gr. The recoil is not punishing at all. The former situation minimizes the subjective recoil, while the latter maximizes subjective recoil. Shotgun Gauges Explained 10 Vs 12 16 20 28 410 Big Hunting. Watch later. However, you risk ruining the meat of these small-game animals when hunting with a 12-gauge. slickwillie":2augkcd3 said: Geez guys for the cost of M2, custom cerakote, aftermarket turkey choke, etc. So a .270 Winchester round exits the barrel with kinetic energy equal to the energy required for linear vertical displacement of 3780 pounds through a one foot distance, while a .30-30 Winchester round exiting the barrel has energy equal to the amount required to displace 1890 pounds over the same one foot distance. As you might have The real advantage of 20 gauge is being able to hit your target for multiple shots or multiple targets. 870 is all any of us really need,recoil is not an issue with any 20ga. On the other hand, the .45-70 leaves the muzzle with an energy of 2,280 ft-lbs and, after 200 yards, strikes a target with 1,305 ft-lbs. Oh, I suggest you consider the 150 gr ya don't need more than that. I personally like the .450 much better than the 45-70, but also have come to dread pulling the trigger! Thats why hunters may prefer them since they give them a better chance of hitting the target. To start, lets get a sense of each cartridges history. In order to give a realistic idea of how much various shotgun and rifle loads are liable to kick the shooter, the recoil figures below are for hunting guns of typical weight for their caliber or gauge. Because I'm the young buck of the camp (at 38 years old), I'm the "dog" when it comes to deer drives. Several people will use 12-gauge loads for big-game hunting, as well. with it's new tip, it allows pointed bullets to be safely loaded in the 30-30 without fear of a round detonation in the mag tube from recoil. Cowboys draft pick accused of multiple violent acts, Colorado woman killed in suspected bear attack, 90 found in home; smuggling operation suspected, Jets select 2 players with same name in NFL draft, After Biden speech, N. Korea warns of 'grave situation'. The list below provides some objective answers. For comparison my .458 Winchester Magnum has a recoil index of 62.3 lbs. Difference is that the .54 is a much lighter rifle, hence the perceived recoil is greater. It really drops 'em. Since your rifle has a tubular magazine, I strongly recommend using soft-point ammunition -- it is far less likely to ignite the primer in front of it if you happen to "bump" the rifle butt-first on a hard surface (don't even try it "just to see what happens" - you might not live to tell the tale; never mind that it's rough on the rifle). Many pellets may strike a bird, or animal with sufficient killing power to give a lethal shot. 20-gauge shotshellMany might consider this one borderline, but lets run some numbers based on popular target loads: 28-gauge -ounce-12.8 ft.-lbs. On the other hand, 12 gauge offer smooth-swing and comfort of use and therefore, a great gun for defense as well as upland shooting. Mag. of recoil with the 150 grain bullet and 11.0 lbs. Listen to a little of everything you get here and try it for yourself. The 12 gauge produces even more recoil than that. The recoil kinetic energy figures below are taken from the Rifle Recoil Table and the Shotgun Recoil Table. The 20 gauge with #13 shot throws out 10 .30 caliber pellets versus a 12 gauge with 00 buckshot with 8 pellets of .33 caliber. Your odds are certainly better at longer distances with a 12-gauge if you're using buckshot loads. Is influencer Meena Harris exploiting family ties? It happens that small gauge field shotguns typically weigh less than small bore hunting rifles, while the weight of large bore field shotguns (12 and 10 gauge) are more generally comparable to the weight of larger caliber hunting rifles. There is no really simple answer to your post as you can see, so I'll quit rambling. This color marking avoids getting mixed up, seeing as these In the interest of brevity and to facilitate comparison, I have listed only reasonably well known rifle calibers/loads and shotgun gauges/loads that are similar in recoil energy. I was going to also advise to try Hornady's lever ammo, but that has been touched on already. I like the way the Winchester expands on deer. In fact, according to Hawks' recoil table even the 20 gauge produces more recoil than the .30-30 Winchester. while the heaviest recoiling one is rated at 54.0 lbs. 06-29-2013, 12:55 AM. Many people described the recoil as half of that of a 12 gauge. Bottom line. Now, check out this 12 Gauge shell with a 1 oz slug and 1,560 fps muzzle velocity. Call us at (540) 898-9256, If you have questions. Even though the recoil of the 12 gauge Versa Max is about the same (maybe even slightly less) than the 20 gauge youth model semi auto - that isn't the reason she has a 20 gauge. The 30-30 will be a piece of cake As for rounds, Hornady has started making a new 30-30 round that will give you a range of 250-300 yards in a 30-30. it has a composit tip that allows you to tube load the round and it will give you the max. The .30-30 has a muzzle energy of 1,902 ft-lbs; after 200 yards, that drops to 947 ft-lbs. Shotgun Recoil Chart Amr. In comparison, my Marlin 336 in 30-30 with a 150 grain bullet recoils like kitten. The 12 gauge produces even more recoil than that.

10 Advantages Of Marriage, Pokemon Trading Card Game Gameboy Walkthrough, Top Engineering Consulting Firms Uk 2019, How To Swap Two Elements In An Arraylist Java, Project On Apple Company Pdf, Jimmy Neutron Meme Template, Ring Doorbell Mounting Accessories,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *